Explore Properties In Casey Key, FL

Casey Key, FL is one of Sarasota’s hidden gems, offering a serene and luxurious escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Whether you’re looking for a sprawling estate or a cozy beach home, you can find it on Casey Key.

The island has miles of beach to walk and secluded coves where you can enjoy the calm waters and stunning coastal views. And when it comes to housing, Casey Key boasts some of the most incredible properties in the area.

We can and will help you explore the area to find the perfect property you’re seeking. Casey Key is a truly special place – come see for yourself!

Casey Key Homes For Sale

About Casey Key, FL

Casey Key is a narrow, eight-mile-long island off the coast of Sarasota. The island is home to 400 single-family homes, from sprawling estates to cozy beach cottages and everything in between. Due to its narrow width, Casey Key has a quiet, serene atmosphere and has a direct view of the stunning Gulf of Mexico.

The island’s road adds to the laid-back feeling Casey Key exudes. The tranquility of the place is one of its main attractions – it’s a place where you can truly relax and escape the stresses of everyday life.

With no present traffic lights or stop signs, the only thing you’ll have to worry about on Casey Key is finding the perfect spot to enjoy the incredible views. The astonishing white-sand beaches and crystal-clear waters in the coves are a sight to behold, making this island an ideal spot for those looking to unwind or enjoy.

If you are into collecting interesting things, there are loads of opportunities to discover on Casey Key. For one, just off the coast of Casey Key, FL, a large number of great white sharks’ lives are claimed by the waters.

As a result, the ocean around Casey Key is thought to be one of the best spots in Florida to do shark teeth hunting. You can find these fossils on the beach or even in the water while swimming – a fun activity for the whole family!

casey key fl
casey key fl

Be One of the Few Homeowners on Casey Key, FL

If you are looking to add up value to your property portfolio or just want to have an incredible home by the sea, Casey Key is the place for you.  With its serene atmosphere and jaw-dropping views, this place surely is a hotspot for investment properties.

If you are interested to explore the area and seeing the properties available, feel free to contact us. We would be more than happy to help you find your dream home in Casey Key, FL. You can reach us at +1 941-544-7690 or shayla@sarasotarealestatesold.com.

What People Say About Working With Us

Shayla has bought 4 condos for me and sold 3 over the last 10 years. I couldn’t be happier with her amazing attentive service.. Shayla and her team are amazing and always on top of everything during the whole process. Her main assistant Shaela (not Shayla ) is also incredible to deal with. I highly recommend you use Shayla and her team for all your real estate needs.


Shayla and her experienced team do it all. They are networked into the community here locally and nothing is more important than being able to pick up the phone and connect buyers and sellers. When there was a showing, and the alarm was malfunctioning, who hashed it out on the spot with the alarm company and made sure the showing went well, Shayla did. The technology is superior, Docusign and paperless contracts make changes a breeze, I did almost everything from my phone. Do not rely on a part time Realtor who does 2 closings a year. Go with a pro who is young, hungry, and knows the ropes of the industry.

Robert Melberth